Ignite Creation Date:
2024-05-06 @ 8:37 AM
Last Modification Date:
2024-10-26 @ 12:02 PM
Study NCT ID:
NCT02776332
Status:
UNKNOWN
Last Update Posted:
2018-09-06
First Post:
2016-05-12
Brief Title:
The Merit Study Manual Expression pRemature InfanTs
Sponsor:
St Louis Childrens Hospital
Organization:
St Louis Childrens Hospital
Study Overview
Official Title:
A Randomized Controlled Trial Comparing The Effect Of Duration Of Manual Expression And Breastfeeding Self-efficacy On Milk Volumes In Mothers Of Premature Infants
Status:
UNKNOWN
Status Verified Date:
2018-09
Last Known Status:
ACTIVE_NOT_RECRUITING
Delayed Posting:
No
If Stopped, Why?:
Not Stopped
Has Expanded Access:
False
If Expanded Access, NCT#:
N/A
Has Expanded Access, NCT# Status:
N/A
Acronym:
MERIT
Brief Summary:
The purpose of this study is to determine how the duration of manual expression affects milk volumes and levels of breastfeeding self-efficacy in mothers of premature infants
The specific aims of this study are to determine if the duration of manual expression in mothers of premature infants will result in a an increase in breastfeeding self-efficacy b a difference in milk volume and c a correlation between breastfeeding self-efficacy and milk volume
The specific aims of this study are to determine if the duration of manual expression in mothers of premature infants will result in a an increase in breastfeeding self-efficacy b a difference in milk volume and c a correlation between breastfeeding self-efficacy and milk volume
Detailed Description:
Manual Expression of Breast Milk One of the major contributing factors for the cessation of breast feeding in the premature population of infants is decreased milk production Because most premature infants are unable to initially feed at the breast artificial methods to maintain milk supply such as manual and electric pump expression have been explored
Studies by Flaherman et al and Slusher et al both used a randomized design to address manual versus pump expression and its effect on milk volume Flaherman et al studied a population of 68 full-term infants feeding poorly at the breast for two months after delivery in a United States academic medical center and randomized the mother to either manual expression or electric pump expression Slusher et al allocated mothers of 65 premature infants admitted to an African special care nursery to manual expression manual powered pedal pump or an electric pump for six-ten days after delivery Both studies found the electric pump to yield higher volumes of milk than manual expression Slusher et al found a statistically significant increase in milk volume with the electric pump when compared to manual expression p001 No mean differences in demographics between the three groups were found Flaherman et al also reported higher milk volumes with the electric pump but the comparison failed to reach statistical significance p007 Although failing to reach statistical significance on milk volume Flaherman followed participants for two months and reported higher rates of continued breastfeeding among the mothers who had initially used hand expression p002 In addition Flaherman measured self -efficacy using the Breastfeeding Self-Efficacy Scale-Short Form BSES-SF at baseline one week one moth and two months after delivery However there were no significant differences between the groups for breastfeeding self-efficacy
Two studies investigated a combination of manual and electric pump expression Morton combined hand expression and electric pumping whereas Ohyama used manual expression or electric pump expression In the study by Morton a prospective observational design was used to examine milk production for eight weeks after delivery for mothers who were instructed to use an electric pump and manually express as much as possible in the first three days post-partum with no particular sequencing In this sample of 67 mothers of premature infants Morton was able to find an increased milk production at two weeks for those mothers that hand expressed greater than five times a day p005 Ohyama also studied mothers of premature infants in a Japanese neonatal intensive care unit using a crossover design that studied a combination of manual and electric pump expression techniques The mothers were sequentially allocated to either manual or electric pump expression and then alternated the method until seven sessions had been completed for each method Net milk yield was significantly higher with manual expression p005 as compared to pump expression in the first 48 hours after delivery Both of these studies support the potential benefit of manual expression for early removal of colostrum prior to the onset of mature milk
A pilot feasibility study using a combined sequence of manual and pump expression intervention for the first three days after delivery was conducted on the mothers of premature infants whose infants were hospitalized in a NICU in the proposed study population and setting Mothers of premature infants n6 were asked by staff nurses in the intra-partum and post-partum units to perform manual expression prior to electric pump expression for the first three days after delivery and record milk volumes on a breastfeeding log for three weeks after delivery Women who had not begun an initial expression within six hours after delivery were initially excluded based on previous literature that states the longer the delay in time from delivery to expression can serve as an important variable in overall milk production Due to the infeasibility of the women being able to begin their first pumping session within six hours of delivery due to complications of delivery or other logistical issues within the healthcare setting the inclusion criteria for recruitment was extended from six hours to 24 hours after delivery The intervention of manual expression was able to be delivered on all of the mothers in the study thus providing important information on the feasibility of teaching this intervention in this population of mothers However because only half of the mothers in the study were able to complete the log revisions in the amount and duration of study variables for the larger study have been considered
Limitations of Previous Studies on Manual Expression Of the studies reviewed only three addressed premature infants and only two were randomized trials thus causation is difficult to establish There was conflicting evidence whether electric pump expression or manual expression yielded higher milk volumes and a standard sequencing method was not always employed in the research design All of the studies reported relatively low sample sizes and failed to mention the use of a power analysis which can lead to a Type I error Most of the studies were focused on physiological outcomes as the primary measure and did not incorporate a theoretical framework The studies were based on the physiological theory that early and frequent pump expression after delivery is essential to maintain milk supply in mothers who may be separated from their infants or when infants are feeding poorly
Despite the mixed results of previous studies it is becoming standard practice for many hospitals to instruct all mothers on manual expression as a result of the recommendation of the Baby-Friendly Hospital Initiative BFHI The BFHI is a global initiative endorsed by WHO and the United Nations Childrens Fund UNICEF whose primary goal is to assist all mothers in being able to successfully initiate and sustain breastfeeding The BFHI recognizes hospitals that are successful in meeting their guidelines for breastfeeding quality and outcomes The number of US hospitals applying for the BFHI certification has increased since 2010 when the US Department of Health and Human Services incorporated the practices promoted into federal goals As part of the BFHI global criteria 80 of mothers need to report that they have been taught how to hand express their milk for both mothers feeding at the breast and for those mothers who are separated from their babies The duration of manual expression was not defined by the BFHI and previous studies incorporating manual expression have not measured how many days of manual expression may be optimal Of the studies reviewed that incorporated manual expression as an independent variable most were not in combination with electric pump expression The duration of manual expression varied across all studies anywhere from three to eight days after delivery
As previously discussed lactogenesis II is marked by the onset of copious milk secretion after birth and the delivery of the placenta and occurs anywhere from two to eight days postpartum Due to the variability of when mature milk is created the timing of the colostrum period may vary per individual Comparing the duration of manual expression may reveal insights into the optimal timing of this expression technique for mothers of premature infants No studies reviewed focused on the duration of manual expression as an independent variable This study will be the first to focus on the duration of manual expression as the primary variable of interest
Studies by Flaherman et al and Slusher et al both used a randomized design to address manual versus pump expression and its effect on milk volume Flaherman et al studied a population of 68 full-term infants feeding poorly at the breast for two months after delivery in a United States academic medical center and randomized the mother to either manual expression or electric pump expression Slusher et al allocated mothers of 65 premature infants admitted to an African special care nursery to manual expression manual powered pedal pump or an electric pump for six-ten days after delivery Both studies found the electric pump to yield higher volumes of milk than manual expression Slusher et al found a statistically significant increase in milk volume with the electric pump when compared to manual expression p001 No mean differences in demographics between the three groups were found Flaherman et al also reported higher milk volumes with the electric pump but the comparison failed to reach statistical significance p007 Although failing to reach statistical significance on milk volume Flaherman followed participants for two months and reported higher rates of continued breastfeeding among the mothers who had initially used hand expression p002 In addition Flaherman measured self -efficacy using the Breastfeeding Self-Efficacy Scale-Short Form BSES-SF at baseline one week one moth and two months after delivery However there were no significant differences between the groups for breastfeeding self-efficacy
Two studies investigated a combination of manual and electric pump expression Morton combined hand expression and electric pumping whereas Ohyama used manual expression or electric pump expression In the study by Morton a prospective observational design was used to examine milk production for eight weeks after delivery for mothers who were instructed to use an electric pump and manually express as much as possible in the first three days post-partum with no particular sequencing In this sample of 67 mothers of premature infants Morton was able to find an increased milk production at two weeks for those mothers that hand expressed greater than five times a day p005 Ohyama also studied mothers of premature infants in a Japanese neonatal intensive care unit using a crossover design that studied a combination of manual and electric pump expression techniques The mothers were sequentially allocated to either manual or electric pump expression and then alternated the method until seven sessions had been completed for each method Net milk yield was significantly higher with manual expression p005 as compared to pump expression in the first 48 hours after delivery Both of these studies support the potential benefit of manual expression for early removal of colostrum prior to the onset of mature milk
A pilot feasibility study using a combined sequence of manual and pump expression intervention for the first three days after delivery was conducted on the mothers of premature infants whose infants were hospitalized in a NICU in the proposed study population and setting Mothers of premature infants n6 were asked by staff nurses in the intra-partum and post-partum units to perform manual expression prior to electric pump expression for the first three days after delivery and record milk volumes on a breastfeeding log for three weeks after delivery Women who had not begun an initial expression within six hours after delivery were initially excluded based on previous literature that states the longer the delay in time from delivery to expression can serve as an important variable in overall milk production Due to the infeasibility of the women being able to begin their first pumping session within six hours of delivery due to complications of delivery or other logistical issues within the healthcare setting the inclusion criteria for recruitment was extended from six hours to 24 hours after delivery The intervention of manual expression was able to be delivered on all of the mothers in the study thus providing important information on the feasibility of teaching this intervention in this population of mothers However because only half of the mothers in the study were able to complete the log revisions in the amount and duration of study variables for the larger study have been considered
Limitations of Previous Studies on Manual Expression Of the studies reviewed only three addressed premature infants and only two were randomized trials thus causation is difficult to establish There was conflicting evidence whether electric pump expression or manual expression yielded higher milk volumes and a standard sequencing method was not always employed in the research design All of the studies reported relatively low sample sizes and failed to mention the use of a power analysis which can lead to a Type I error Most of the studies were focused on physiological outcomes as the primary measure and did not incorporate a theoretical framework The studies were based on the physiological theory that early and frequent pump expression after delivery is essential to maintain milk supply in mothers who may be separated from their infants or when infants are feeding poorly
Despite the mixed results of previous studies it is becoming standard practice for many hospitals to instruct all mothers on manual expression as a result of the recommendation of the Baby-Friendly Hospital Initiative BFHI The BFHI is a global initiative endorsed by WHO and the United Nations Childrens Fund UNICEF whose primary goal is to assist all mothers in being able to successfully initiate and sustain breastfeeding The BFHI recognizes hospitals that are successful in meeting their guidelines for breastfeeding quality and outcomes The number of US hospitals applying for the BFHI certification has increased since 2010 when the US Department of Health and Human Services incorporated the practices promoted into federal goals As part of the BFHI global criteria 80 of mothers need to report that they have been taught how to hand express their milk for both mothers feeding at the breast and for those mothers who are separated from their babies The duration of manual expression was not defined by the BFHI and previous studies incorporating manual expression have not measured how many days of manual expression may be optimal Of the studies reviewed that incorporated manual expression as an independent variable most were not in combination with electric pump expression The duration of manual expression varied across all studies anywhere from three to eight days after delivery
As previously discussed lactogenesis II is marked by the onset of copious milk secretion after birth and the delivery of the placenta and occurs anywhere from two to eight days postpartum Due to the variability of when mature milk is created the timing of the colostrum period may vary per individual Comparing the duration of manual expression may reveal insights into the optimal timing of this expression technique for mothers of premature infants No studies reviewed focused on the duration of manual expression as an independent variable This study will be the first to focus on the duration of manual expression as the primary variable of interest
Study Oversight
Has Oversight DMC:
None
Is a FDA Regulated Drug?:
None
Is a FDA Regulated Device?:
None
Is an Unapproved Device?:
None
Is a PPSD?:
None
Is a US Export?:
None
Is an FDA AA801 Violation?:
None