Ignite Creation Date:
2024-07-17 @ 11:28 AM
Last Modification Date:
2024-10-26 @ 3:33 PM
Study NCT ID:
NCT06481657
Status:
COMPLETED
Last Update Posted:
2024-07-01
First Post:
2024-06-25
Brief Title:
The Effect of Oxygen Supplementation in Training in Heart Failure Patients on Aerobic Performance and Quality of Life
Sponsor:
Laniado Hospital
Organization:
Laniado Hospital
Study Overview
Official Title:
The Effect of Oxygen Supplementation in Training in Heart Failure Patients on Aerobic Performance and Quality of Life
Status:
COMPLETED
Status Verified Date:
2024-06
Last Known Status:
None
Delayed Posting:
No
If Stopped, Why?:
Not Stopped
Has Expanded Access:
False
If Expanded Access, NCT#:
N/A
Has Expanded Access, NCT# Status:
N/A
Acronym:
None
Brief Summary:
Background Physical training in patients with heart failure has been proven to reduce mortality and hospitalization rates but many have difficulty performing an effort due to a lack of oxygen supply to the muscle and its fatigue The effect of supplementing oxygen in a single effort was found to improve the level of oxygen reaching the muscle the duration and intensity of the effort
The effect of supplemental oxygen during an exercise program in heart failure patients on exercise performance has not yet been examined
The aims of the study 1 To test the effect of a training program with oxygen supplementation on maximal and submaximal aerobic exercise six-minute walk 6MWT and quality of life in patients with heart failure 2 Testing the effect of oxygen supplementation in a single effort on the lactate concentration and performance of the effort
Methods 24 independent heart failure patients without a decrease in saturation with an ejection fraction 50 were recruited for the study and were randomly divided into two groups a training group with supplemental oxygen O2 and a control group that trained without supplemental oxygen Before and after a training program that lasted two months the following were tested maximal aerobic power submaximal aerobic exercise time 6MWT disease severity according to the New York Heart Association - NYHA and quality of life according to the Kansas Questionnaire KCCQ In addition a single submaximal effort was performed at 80 of maximum heart rate with and without oxygen supplementation Every 3 minutes the lactate concentration heart rate and the difficulty of the effort were measured To test the effect of the intervention on the outcome measures a 2way ANOVA test was performed for repeated measurements
Importance of the study The results of the study will make it possible to examine for the first time the effect and importance of oxygen supplementation during training in cardiac rehabilitation settings On aerobic training indices and quality of life
The effect of supplemental oxygen during an exercise program in heart failure patients on exercise performance has not yet been examined
The aims of the study 1 To test the effect of a training program with oxygen supplementation on maximal and submaximal aerobic exercise six-minute walk 6MWT and quality of life in patients with heart failure 2 Testing the effect of oxygen supplementation in a single effort on the lactate concentration and performance of the effort
Methods 24 independent heart failure patients without a decrease in saturation with an ejection fraction 50 were recruited for the study and were randomly divided into two groups a training group with supplemental oxygen O2 and a control group that trained without supplemental oxygen Before and after a training program that lasted two months the following were tested maximal aerobic power submaximal aerobic exercise time 6MWT disease severity according to the New York Heart Association - NYHA and quality of life according to the Kansas Questionnaire KCCQ In addition a single submaximal effort was performed at 80 of maximum heart rate with and without oxygen supplementation Every 3 minutes the lactate concentration heart rate and the difficulty of the effort were measured To test the effect of the intervention on the outcome measures a 2way ANOVA test was performed for repeated measurements
Importance of the study The results of the study will make it possible to examine for the first time the effect and importance of oxygen supplementation during training in cardiac rehabilitation settings On aerobic training indices and quality of life
Detailed Description:
The study population The study recruited 24 patients with heart failure who came to the cardiac rehabilitation program at Laniado Hospital who met the inclusion criteria After receiving an explanation of the study the participants were asked to sign an informed consent form and were randomly divided into 2 training groups with and without oxygen administration A sample using G-power software medium effect size 03 power 08 and an error of 005 was found to be equal to 24 participants
Measurement and evaluation tool
Maximum effort protocol to assess the maximum aerobic capacity a graded exercise test was performed on a moving track according to the Bruce protocol which began by walking at 24 kmh and a 10 incline every three minutes the incline and speed were increased until the subject reported that heshe could not continue any longer At the end of each step the heart rate was recorded Heart rate and the subjective degree of difficulty according to the Borg scale The last stage reached by the subject was used to determine multiple values calculated heart rate and maximum oxygen consumption
Aerobic submaximal exercise protocol the test consisted of walking on a track at an incline and speed determined according to the phase corresponding to the Bruce protocol in which the patient reached 80 of the maximum heart rate at the beginning of the training program the participant was asked to persist in walking until he could not continue at the required pace and reached fatigue Record the time and distance until the end of the effort
A submaximal exercise protocol to compare single exercise conditions with and without oxygen In order to compare the effect of supplementing oxygen in a single exercise some of the participants n20 performed a submaximal exercise protocol with and without oxygen in two consecutive sessions and in random order The tests were performed on a rail at an incline and speed determined according to the phase corresponding to the Bruce protocol in which the patient reached 80 of the heart rate In the test under oxygen conditions oxygen supplementation of 20 5 liters per minute was given using oxygen goggles and in the test under conditions without oxygen supplementation placebo room air was given 5 liters per minute using oxygen goggles Every three minutes the heart rate was recorded the feeling of exertion and the level of lactic acid in the blood the time and distance that the participants gulped until they reported that they could not continue with the given effort was recorded The tests were done within 72 hours and in random order
Calculation of metabolic expenditure METs Metabolic Equivalent of Task one METs defines the amount of oxygen consumption at rest sitting in a chair and is equal to 35 ml of oxygen per kilogram of body per minute METs during the training program in effort on a track is calculated according to speed and gradient according to The following formula METs01Xspeed18XspeedXgrade3535 Metabolic expenditure in the maximal effort protocol was calculated for each minute during the Bruce protocol
Borg scale a reliable and valid subjective tool for assessing difficulty when performing an effort where a rating of 6 indicates no effort at all while a score of 20 indicates maximum effort The level of lactic acid in the blood measured using Lactate Scout Lactic acid levels were measured before the start of the test while resting on a chair and with effort every 3 minutes and at the end of the test
Calculation of target heart rate in training according to the Karbonan formula target heart rate at the beginning of training is calculated as 50 of the heart rate reserve according to the following formula resting heart rate 50 percentage of maximum capacity X maximum heart rate - resting heart rate
Functional test for assessing walking ability 6MWT Six Minute Walk Test a clinical test used to assess aerobic capacity which is found to be reliable and valid for assessing the functional status of heart failure patients The test includes a six-minute walk where the instruction is given to walk the maximum distance that can be achieved in six minutes
Questionnaire to assess quality of life in heart failure patients The Kansas City Cardiomyopathy Questionnaire KCCQ This questionnaire was found to be valid reliable and sensitive to quality of life in heart failure patients The questionnaire consists of 23 questions where a higher score indicates a higher quality of life The sections of each question are divided by a hundred according to the number of possible answers in each section when you can get a maximum of one hundred points for each question The overall score is an average of all sections
A score below 45 indicates a poor quality of life An improvement in the overall score of 5 points indicates a slight improvement an improvement of 10 points indicates a moderate improvement and an improvement of 20 points indicates a great improvement in the quality of life In addition an improvement in the overall score of 5 points indicates a reduction of approximately 7 in the risk of death or hospitalization And every 10-point improvement indicates a 14 reduction in the risk of death or hospitalizationDisease severity index - New York Heart Association - NYHA a valid and accepted index for assessing the severity of the disease based on symptoms of shortness of breath Power throughout the training program during the training program the speed and incline that the participants walked on the treadmill were measured at 4 time points and the METs were calculated according to the following formula METs01Xspeed18XspeedXgrade3535
The strength of the training in resistance exercises in the second month of the training 2 resistance exercises were combined for the patients One for the upper limbs and one for the lower limbs for the exercisers choice the weight was adjusted at which the participant was able to perform 15 repetitions while reporting a degree of difficulty of 15 hard effort on the Borg scale RPE-15
54 Research Process Upon admission of the patients to the Balneado Cardiac Rehabilitation Center a cardiologists assessment was performed to check inclusion criteria and release them to the study At this stage the doctor or physiotherapist made an appeal to those who met the inclusion criteria to participate in the study After a detailed explanation of the study and its requirements those interested in participating were asked to give their consent in writing and were given Randomized to one of two groups with oxygen and a control group Both groups trained with oxygen goggles during all aerobic efforts throughout the training program the O2 group trained with oxygen supplementation of 5 Lmin and the control group trained without oxygen enrichment with air flow room placebo
In the first week upon admission to rehabilitation the patients underwent a graded exercise test until fatigue according to the Bruce protocol At the end of each step of the protocol heart rate data was collected from the heart rate monitor and the level of difficulty according to a report 50 of the heart rate reserve according to the maximum heart rate reached by the patient in the graded exercise test In this session the participants filled out the Kansas Quality of Life Questionnaire the severity of the disease was rated according to the NYHA rating and a six-minute walk test was performed
In the second week the patients in both groups performed 2 submaximal tests on a track at a speed and gradient corresponding to the stage at which they reached 80 of the maximum heart rate in the maximum test This test was done with oxygen goggles with added oxygen and without it placebo in random order with a difference of 72 hours between the tests Heart rate RPE and lactic acid concentration were sampled in all the trainees until the end of the test
During the training program which lasted 8 weeks and included two sessions per week one hour each the participants exercised according to the target heart rate determined by the physiologist at RPE 13 Throughout the training program if the patient reported an RPE lower than 12 for the target heart rate given to him The target heart rate was increased according to the heart rate reserve by 5
The course of the training in the first month included five minutes of warm-up then 20 minutes of walking on a track 15 minutes of cycling ten minutes of aerobic equipment of each participants choice and finally five minutes of active recovery In the second month after walking and cycling two strength exercises were combined one for lower limbs and one for upper limbs according to the exercisers choice for each exercise 3 sets of 10-15 repetitions were performed at a hard effort level RPE-15 The intensity of effort in each training session was recorded for each participant At the end of the program after 8 weeks an additional assessment of maximal aerobic capacity was performed using a maximal graded exercise test a continuous submaximal test until fatigue according to the stage in the Bruce protocol that the patient performed at the beginning of the program These two tests were performed for both groups without oxygen supplementation In addition the participants were asked to fill out a Kansas Quality of Life questionnaire and perform a six-minute walk test
55 Data Analysis Descriptive statistics were performed to describe the study population for demographic anthropometric variables disease characteristics years of illness and NYHA score functional indices and quality of life questionnaire score All variables were tested for normal distribution by the Smirnoff Kolmogorov test Variables that were not normally distributed were monotonically transformed and retested for normal distribution Variables found to be normal were reported as mean and standard deviation and variables not normally distributed NYHA were reported as median and quartiles
In order to test the differences between the 2 groups in the outcome measures maximum power in a maximal effort test time and distance in a submaximal test a six-minute walk test and a quality of life questionnaire score a 2 way ANOVA mixed model repeated measures analysis model was used to find a central effect of group O2 control time before and after training and the interaction between them time x group if the interaction was found to be significant a simple mean analysis was performed to check the source of the difference
For the NYHA score an ordinal variable the PROC GENMODE procedure was used which allowed the use of a 2 way ANOVA model To find the difference in the severity of the disease in the two groups before and after the training program
In testing the difference between the groups in training power according to METs at 4 different times in the weeks W of the training program W1 W3 W6 W8 a Bonferroni type post hoc analysis was conducted to test the source of the differences
In order to test the differences between performing a single submaximal exercise test with and without oxygen supplementation of each participant within in measures of the feeling of exertion RPE heart rate and lactic acid levels at each stage the slope was calculated throughout the time each test lasted A smaller slope indicates a more moderate increase in the tested variable over time and expresses better aerobic capacity at submaximal power Differences in slopes between performing a submaximal test with and without oxygen were tested by the signed rank test Data analysis was done using SAS software version 94 p 005 was set as money for statistical significance
Measurement and evaluation tool
Maximum effort protocol to assess the maximum aerobic capacity a graded exercise test was performed on a moving track according to the Bruce protocol which began by walking at 24 kmh and a 10 incline every three minutes the incline and speed were increased until the subject reported that heshe could not continue any longer At the end of each step the heart rate was recorded Heart rate and the subjective degree of difficulty according to the Borg scale The last stage reached by the subject was used to determine multiple values calculated heart rate and maximum oxygen consumption
Aerobic submaximal exercise protocol the test consisted of walking on a track at an incline and speed determined according to the phase corresponding to the Bruce protocol in which the patient reached 80 of the maximum heart rate at the beginning of the training program the participant was asked to persist in walking until he could not continue at the required pace and reached fatigue Record the time and distance until the end of the effort
A submaximal exercise protocol to compare single exercise conditions with and without oxygen In order to compare the effect of supplementing oxygen in a single exercise some of the participants n20 performed a submaximal exercise protocol with and without oxygen in two consecutive sessions and in random order The tests were performed on a rail at an incline and speed determined according to the phase corresponding to the Bruce protocol in which the patient reached 80 of the heart rate In the test under oxygen conditions oxygen supplementation of 20 5 liters per minute was given using oxygen goggles and in the test under conditions without oxygen supplementation placebo room air was given 5 liters per minute using oxygen goggles Every three minutes the heart rate was recorded the feeling of exertion and the level of lactic acid in the blood the time and distance that the participants gulped until they reported that they could not continue with the given effort was recorded The tests were done within 72 hours and in random order
Calculation of metabolic expenditure METs Metabolic Equivalent of Task one METs defines the amount of oxygen consumption at rest sitting in a chair and is equal to 35 ml of oxygen per kilogram of body per minute METs during the training program in effort on a track is calculated according to speed and gradient according to The following formula METs01Xspeed18XspeedXgrade3535 Metabolic expenditure in the maximal effort protocol was calculated for each minute during the Bruce protocol
Borg scale a reliable and valid subjective tool for assessing difficulty when performing an effort where a rating of 6 indicates no effort at all while a score of 20 indicates maximum effort The level of lactic acid in the blood measured using Lactate Scout Lactic acid levels were measured before the start of the test while resting on a chair and with effort every 3 minutes and at the end of the test
Calculation of target heart rate in training according to the Karbonan formula target heart rate at the beginning of training is calculated as 50 of the heart rate reserve according to the following formula resting heart rate 50 percentage of maximum capacity X maximum heart rate - resting heart rate
Functional test for assessing walking ability 6MWT Six Minute Walk Test a clinical test used to assess aerobic capacity which is found to be reliable and valid for assessing the functional status of heart failure patients The test includes a six-minute walk where the instruction is given to walk the maximum distance that can be achieved in six minutes
Questionnaire to assess quality of life in heart failure patients The Kansas City Cardiomyopathy Questionnaire KCCQ This questionnaire was found to be valid reliable and sensitive to quality of life in heart failure patients The questionnaire consists of 23 questions where a higher score indicates a higher quality of life The sections of each question are divided by a hundred according to the number of possible answers in each section when you can get a maximum of one hundred points for each question The overall score is an average of all sections
A score below 45 indicates a poor quality of life An improvement in the overall score of 5 points indicates a slight improvement an improvement of 10 points indicates a moderate improvement and an improvement of 20 points indicates a great improvement in the quality of life In addition an improvement in the overall score of 5 points indicates a reduction of approximately 7 in the risk of death or hospitalization And every 10-point improvement indicates a 14 reduction in the risk of death or hospitalizationDisease severity index - New York Heart Association - NYHA a valid and accepted index for assessing the severity of the disease based on symptoms of shortness of breath Power throughout the training program during the training program the speed and incline that the participants walked on the treadmill were measured at 4 time points and the METs were calculated according to the following formula METs01Xspeed18XspeedXgrade3535
The strength of the training in resistance exercises in the second month of the training 2 resistance exercises were combined for the patients One for the upper limbs and one for the lower limbs for the exercisers choice the weight was adjusted at which the participant was able to perform 15 repetitions while reporting a degree of difficulty of 15 hard effort on the Borg scale RPE-15
54 Research Process Upon admission of the patients to the Balneado Cardiac Rehabilitation Center a cardiologists assessment was performed to check inclusion criteria and release them to the study At this stage the doctor or physiotherapist made an appeal to those who met the inclusion criteria to participate in the study After a detailed explanation of the study and its requirements those interested in participating were asked to give their consent in writing and were given Randomized to one of two groups with oxygen and a control group Both groups trained with oxygen goggles during all aerobic efforts throughout the training program the O2 group trained with oxygen supplementation of 5 Lmin and the control group trained without oxygen enrichment with air flow room placebo
In the first week upon admission to rehabilitation the patients underwent a graded exercise test until fatigue according to the Bruce protocol At the end of each step of the protocol heart rate data was collected from the heart rate monitor and the level of difficulty according to a report 50 of the heart rate reserve according to the maximum heart rate reached by the patient in the graded exercise test In this session the participants filled out the Kansas Quality of Life Questionnaire the severity of the disease was rated according to the NYHA rating and a six-minute walk test was performed
In the second week the patients in both groups performed 2 submaximal tests on a track at a speed and gradient corresponding to the stage at which they reached 80 of the maximum heart rate in the maximum test This test was done with oxygen goggles with added oxygen and without it placebo in random order with a difference of 72 hours between the tests Heart rate RPE and lactic acid concentration were sampled in all the trainees until the end of the test
During the training program which lasted 8 weeks and included two sessions per week one hour each the participants exercised according to the target heart rate determined by the physiologist at RPE 13 Throughout the training program if the patient reported an RPE lower than 12 for the target heart rate given to him The target heart rate was increased according to the heart rate reserve by 5
The course of the training in the first month included five minutes of warm-up then 20 minutes of walking on a track 15 minutes of cycling ten minutes of aerobic equipment of each participants choice and finally five minutes of active recovery In the second month after walking and cycling two strength exercises were combined one for lower limbs and one for upper limbs according to the exercisers choice for each exercise 3 sets of 10-15 repetitions were performed at a hard effort level RPE-15 The intensity of effort in each training session was recorded for each participant At the end of the program after 8 weeks an additional assessment of maximal aerobic capacity was performed using a maximal graded exercise test a continuous submaximal test until fatigue according to the stage in the Bruce protocol that the patient performed at the beginning of the program These two tests were performed for both groups without oxygen supplementation In addition the participants were asked to fill out a Kansas Quality of Life questionnaire and perform a six-minute walk test
55 Data Analysis Descriptive statistics were performed to describe the study population for demographic anthropometric variables disease characteristics years of illness and NYHA score functional indices and quality of life questionnaire score All variables were tested for normal distribution by the Smirnoff Kolmogorov test Variables that were not normally distributed were monotonically transformed and retested for normal distribution Variables found to be normal were reported as mean and standard deviation and variables not normally distributed NYHA were reported as median and quartiles
In order to test the differences between the 2 groups in the outcome measures maximum power in a maximal effort test time and distance in a submaximal test a six-minute walk test and a quality of life questionnaire score a 2 way ANOVA mixed model repeated measures analysis model was used to find a central effect of group O2 control time before and after training and the interaction between them time x group if the interaction was found to be significant a simple mean analysis was performed to check the source of the difference
For the NYHA score an ordinal variable the PROC GENMODE procedure was used which allowed the use of a 2 way ANOVA model To find the difference in the severity of the disease in the two groups before and after the training program
In testing the difference between the groups in training power according to METs at 4 different times in the weeks W of the training program W1 W3 W6 W8 a Bonferroni type post hoc analysis was conducted to test the source of the differences
In order to test the differences between performing a single submaximal exercise test with and without oxygen supplementation of each participant within in measures of the feeling of exertion RPE heart rate and lactic acid levels at each stage the slope was calculated throughout the time each test lasted A smaller slope indicates a more moderate increase in the tested variable over time and expresses better aerobic capacity at submaximal power Differences in slopes between performing a submaximal test with and without oxygen were tested by the signed rank test Data analysis was done using SAS software version 94 p 005 was set as money for statistical significance
Study Oversight
Has Oversight DMC:
None
Is a FDA Regulated Drug?:
False
Is a FDA Regulated Device?:
False
Is an Unapproved Device?:
None
Is a PPSD?:
None
Is a US Export?:
None
Is an FDA AA801 Violation?:
None