Ignite Creation Date:
2024-10-25 @ 7:53 PM
Last Modification Date:
2024-10-26 @ 3:35 PM
Study NCT ID:
NCT06508918
Status:
COMPLETED
Last Update Posted:
None
First Post:
2023-04-09
Brief Title:
The Effect of Central Sensitization in Radicular Pain in Patients With Failed Low Back Surgery Syndrome
Sponsor:
None
Organization:
None
Study Overview
Official Title:
The Effect of Central Sensitization on the Treatment Success of Ultrasound-Guided Caudal Epidural Steroid Injection in Radicular Pain in Patients With Failed Back Surgery Syndrome
Status:
COMPLETED
Status Verified Date:
2024-08
Last Known Status:
None
Delayed Posting:
No
If Stopped, Why?:
Not Stopped
Has Expanded Access:
No
If Expanded Access, NCT#:
N/A
Has Expanded Access, NCT# Status:
N/A
Acronym:
None
Brief Summary:
The Effect of Central Sensitization in Radicular Pain in Patients with Failed Low Back Surgery Syndrome on Treatment Success of Ultrasound-Guided Caudal Epidural Steroid Injection
Detailed Description:
Low back pain is a very common clinical picture that has a tremendous social financial and psychological impact on the patients life It is a worldwide problem with a global incidence of 94 and causes more disability than any other condition in the world The percentage of adults who experience chronic low back pain throughout their lives ranges from 51 to 84 As the population ages the incidence of surgery for low back pain increases dramatically the number of lumbar fusions increased by 170 from 1998 to 2008 Failed back surgery syndrome FBSS has been reported to affect 10 to 40 of patients following spine surgery but estimating the incidence of FBSS is difficult due to the wide scope of its definition and heterogeneous etiology Failed back surgery syndrome FBSS is defined by the International Association for the Study of Pain as lumbar spinal pain of unknown origin that persists despite surgical intervention or occurs after surgical intervention for pain in the same topographic region Pain may occur after surgery surgery may exacerbate existing pain or not adequately improve it Patients with FBSS have undergone one or more surgical interventions that do not cure long-standing chronic low back pain and pain with or without radicular symptoms Its etiology is complex and it is a condition with many factors that predispose patients to chronic pain Epidural fibrosis perineural scars acquired stenosis recurrent disc herniation or pain of the sacroiliacfacet joints are thought to play a role in the etiology of FBSS Pain in the leg likely indicates nerve compression from stenosis epidural fibrosis or disc herniation while low back pain is more common in facet joint arthropathy sacroiliac joint problems or myofascial etiologies For the failed back surgery syndrome patient physical examination is usually not helpful in identifying a specific aetiology of pain but may reveal several suggestive findings Symptoms from spinal stenosis are usually exacerbated by spinal extension and relieved by flexion On the other hand pain from disc herniation causes a positive straight leg raise test Loss of strength or sensation in the lower extremities can help to understand which nerve roots are affected Other tests may be used to elucidate the etiology of failed back surgery syndrome and differentiate it from other causes of low back pain Erythrocyte sedimentation rate and C-reactive protein can be used to evaluate possible infection especially in patients with structural symptoms or susceptibility to infection Diagnostic nerve blocks can diagnose specific etiologies of FBSS such as facet joint arthropathy medial bundle blocks sacroiliac joint pain lateral bundle branch blocks and intra-articular injection and foraminal stenosis transforaminal epidural and selective unilevel blocks and roots associated with the patients symptoms can define MRI with and without gadolinium contrast remains the gold standard imaging modality for failed back surgery syndrome as it can perfectly detect soft tissue abnormalities such as epidural fibrosis and disc herniation Contrast is particularly indicated in patients with a history of disc herniation surgery A panel of international spine surgeons neurosurgeons and pain specialists with a special interest in FBSS established the Chronic Low Back and Leg Pain CBLP network to address the challenges and barriers in the clinical management of FBSS patients creating a collaborative interdisciplinary body The definition of FBSS proposed by the CBLP network is based on the assumption that no further spine surgery is required after an appropriate somatic radiological and psychosocial assessment The key elements for the definition of FBSS can be summarized in 4 aspects
1 There is low back andor leg pain that persists for at least 6 months after the last spine surgery
2 Patient has undergone a comprehensive clinical and radiological evaluation
3 There is no clear surgical target consistent with the symptoms revealed on clinical examination and imaging
4 There is an interdisciplinary consensus that additional surgical intervention decompression andor fusion is not appropriate
Despite its adverse effects on patients and its relative prevalence in the spine surgery population few high-quality randomized studies have investigated the treatment of FBSS Treatments for FBSS are generally divided into conservative physical therapy or drug therapy and aggressive interventional or surgical management Conservative treatment should always be the first choice before invasive techniques in patients without an indication for emergency surgery Various studies have shown that caudal epidural steroid injection CESI is an effective method in patients with FBSS who do not respond to conservative pain relief treatments Çelenlioğlu A et al investigators compared the success of transforaminal epidural steroid injection TFESI and CESI treatment in patients who developed FBSS after single-level discectomy In two prospective randomized studies both CESI and TFESI transforaminal epidural steroid injection were found to be effective and safe in treatment CESI has been shown to be the safest and simplest ESI with a low complication rate including dural puncture and other side effects compared to other injection methods Yoon et al reported a success rate of 94 with US-guided caudal blockade In a study conducted by Akkaya et al when ultrasound and fluoroscopy-guided caudal epidural steroid injection CESI were compared to patients with FBSS a decrease in both pain and ODI oswestry disabilite indexscores was achieved in both groups at 3-month follow-up and CESI was found to be effective in the treatment of FBSS has been reported In a prospective randomized controlled study comparing the treatment success of caudal epidural steroid injection with ultrasonography USG and fluoroscopy in postlaminectomy patients no difference was found between the two groups in terms of complications while the patients in the fluoroscopy group felt more pain during the procedure than the patients in the USG group Despite correct needle localization and drug injection under fluoroscopy guidance radiation is still a serious risk for both patient and responder The use of USG in caudal epidural injections protects from radiation exposure and is a safe and rapid method for locating the sacral hiatus and guiding the needle Color Doppler USG can view intravenous injections Tsui et al reported that the color Doppler feature of USG could confirm whether the injected drug was diffused to the caudal area Injection of fluid into the epidural space causes turbulent flow which appears as a burst of color while intrathecal injection indicates the absence of color flow Doppler signal Although the precise pathophysiological process of FBSS remains unclear growing evidence suggests that widespread pain distribution hyperalgesia and disproportionate pain intensity symptoms which are also common in other chronic pain-related diseases eg fibromyalgia tension-type headache and nonspecific chronic low back pain are a potential risk factor predicts that central sensitization may develop The International Association for the Study of Pain IASP defined CS in 2011 as the increased response of nociceptive neurons in the central nervous system to normal or sub-threshold afferent inputs Anxiety about pain restriction of daily activities quality of life and the stress associated with it lead to depression over time and thus a vicious cycle of pain-anxiety-depression begins Altered central pain modulation may be involved in the pathogenesis of FBSS Unfortunately only a few studies have investigated the presence of central sensitization although it may guide the treatment of patients with FBSS Central amplification of pain may contribute to both chronic low back pain intensity and disability in FBSS patients Therefore targeted therapies should consider functional changes in the central nervous system of FBSS patients and treatment modalities that can weaken central sensitization eg cognitive-targeted exercise therapy pharmacotherapy spinal cord stimulation may be beneficial in the treatment of FBSS Our aim is to reveal the relationship between FBSS and central sensitization proportionally keeping in mind that central sensitization may develop in post-spinal surgery patients with ongoing pain to prevent the formation of a vicious circle of chronic pain with its early detection and treatment and to prevent the formation of a vicious circle of chronic pain Moreover caudal epidural steroid injection with USG does not have radiation exposure and it is advantageous and beneficial Since it is a reliable method investigators aim to determine its effectiveness in patients with FBSS As far as investigators know such a study has not been reported before in the literature investigators hope that investigators will contribute to the literature
1 There is low back andor leg pain that persists for at least 6 months after the last spine surgery
2 Patient has undergone a comprehensive clinical and radiological evaluation
3 There is no clear surgical target consistent with the symptoms revealed on clinical examination and imaging
4 There is an interdisciplinary consensus that additional surgical intervention decompression andor fusion is not appropriate
Despite its adverse effects on patients and its relative prevalence in the spine surgery population few high-quality randomized studies have investigated the treatment of FBSS Treatments for FBSS are generally divided into conservative physical therapy or drug therapy and aggressive interventional or surgical management Conservative treatment should always be the first choice before invasive techniques in patients without an indication for emergency surgery Various studies have shown that caudal epidural steroid injection CESI is an effective method in patients with FBSS who do not respond to conservative pain relief treatments Çelenlioğlu A et al investigators compared the success of transforaminal epidural steroid injection TFESI and CESI treatment in patients who developed FBSS after single-level discectomy In two prospective randomized studies both CESI and TFESI transforaminal epidural steroid injection were found to be effective and safe in treatment CESI has been shown to be the safest and simplest ESI with a low complication rate including dural puncture and other side effects compared to other injection methods Yoon et al reported a success rate of 94 with US-guided caudal blockade In a study conducted by Akkaya et al when ultrasound and fluoroscopy-guided caudal epidural steroid injection CESI were compared to patients with FBSS a decrease in both pain and ODI oswestry disabilite indexscores was achieved in both groups at 3-month follow-up and CESI was found to be effective in the treatment of FBSS has been reported In a prospective randomized controlled study comparing the treatment success of caudal epidural steroid injection with ultrasonography USG and fluoroscopy in postlaminectomy patients no difference was found between the two groups in terms of complications while the patients in the fluoroscopy group felt more pain during the procedure than the patients in the USG group Despite correct needle localization and drug injection under fluoroscopy guidance radiation is still a serious risk for both patient and responder The use of USG in caudal epidural injections protects from radiation exposure and is a safe and rapid method for locating the sacral hiatus and guiding the needle Color Doppler USG can view intravenous injections Tsui et al reported that the color Doppler feature of USG could confirm whether the injected drug was diffused to the caudal area Injection of fluid into the epidural space causes turbulent flow which appears as a burst of color while intrathecal injection indicates the absence of color flow Doppler signal Although the precise pathophysiological process of FBSS remains unclear growing evidence suggests that widespread pain distribution hyperalgesia and disproportionate pain intensity symptoms which are also common in other chronic pain-related diseases eg fibromyalgia tension-type headache and nonspecific chronic low back pain are a potential risk factor predicts that central sensitization may develop The International Association for the Study of Pain IASP defined CS in 2011 as the increased response of nociceptive neurons in the central nervous system to normal or sub-threshold afferent inputs Anxiety about pain restriction of daily activities quality of life and the stress associated with it lead to depression over time and thus a vicious cycle of pain-anxiety-depression begins Altered central pain modulation may be involved in the pathogenesis of FBSS Unfortunately only a few studies have investigated the presence of central sensitization although it may guide the treatment of patients with FBSS Central amplification of pain may contribute to both chronic low back pain intensity and disability in FBSS patients Therefore targeted therapies should consider functional changes in the central nervous system of FBSS patients and treatment modalities that can weaken central sensitization eg cognitive-targeted exercise therapy pharmacotherapy spinal cord stimulation may be beneficial in the treatment of FBSS Our aim is to reveal the relationship between FBSS and central sensitization proportionally keeping in mind that central sensitization may develop in post-spinal surgery patients with ongoing pain to prevent the formation of a vicious circle of chronic pain with its early detection and treatment and to prevent the formation of a vicious circle of chronic pain Moreover caudal epidural steroid injection with USG does not have radiation exposure and it is advantageous and beneficial Since it is a reliable method investigators aim to determine its effectiveness in patients with FBSS As far as investigators know such a study has not been reported before in the literature investigators hope that investigators will contribute to the literature
Study Oversight
Has Oversight DMC:
None
Is a FDA Regulated Drug?:
None
Is a FDA Regulated Device?:
None
Is an Unapproved Device?:
None
Is a PPSD?:
None
Is a US Export?:
None
Is an FDA AA801 Violation?:
None